Written by Gustavo Mazal
A tax strategy is only as good as its fit with the client. Five questions can tell you whether a planning idea deserves a closer look.
RENDIO | October 2026
Clients Bring You Strategies. Here's How to Vet Them.
Sooner or later, a client forwards you a pitch. A friend used a strategy last year. Someone said it works for people in their bracket. The question lands on your desk: should we do this?
Your role isn't to pitch the strategy or to dismiss it. It's to test whether it fits this client's facts. Five questions do most of that work, and each one starts with the client, not the product.
1. Will You Actually Participate in This Business?
The client moment. Your client, a surgeon with a busy practice, was told that an energy or film project could offset her wage income.
The question to ask. How many hours will you realistically spend in this business, and who else is involved in running it?
Why it matters. Many strategies depend on material participation. Without it, losses and credits are generally passive under IRC §469 and can usually offset only passive income, which many clients don't have enough of. The tests in Treas. Reg. §1.469-5T(a) include participating more than 100 hours and not less than any other individual. The hours have to be real business activity, tracked as they happen, not reconstructed at filing time. Investor-type activities, such as reviewing reports, generally don't count. If the client can't or won't commit the time, that is usually the end of the conversation.
2. How Much of This Benefit Can You Actually Use?
The client moment. Your client had an unusually large income year and heard that a credit could cut the tax bill substantially.
The question to ask. Given your mix of income this year, how much of this credit or loss could you actually use? A projection answers this before anything else.
Why it matters. A credit is only as valuable as the client's ability to use it. Two limits often surprise clients:
Tentative minimum tax (TMT). General business credits, including energy credits, are limited under IRC §38(c), which is tied to tentative minimum tax (Form 6251). In many cases - such as oil and gas - TMT works as a floor; credits generally can't reduce a client's tax below it.
Excess business loss limitation. Under IRC §461(l), business losses above an annual threshold are disallowed for the year and carried forward. This matters most for clients whose income is mainly wages.
Credits rarely eliminate a client's tax entirely. Unused credits can generally be carried to other tax years, within limits, so timing matters as much as the amount.
3. Is This Based on Current Law?
The client moment. Your client looked at a solar project two years ago, set it aside, and has now been shown a similar one.
The question to ask. Which rules does this rely on, and what changed under the 2025 law? This is a fair question for the client and for whoever presented the idea.
Why it matters. The 2025 reconciliation law, commonly called the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), reshaped several categories. It accelerated phase-downs for some energy credits, including certain solar and wind projects, and eligibility now depends heavily on project type and timing. Opportunity Zone rules are also being redefined, and new zone designations depend on state and Treasury action.
For this client, the same project may now face different deadlines or credit amounts, or may not qualify at all, depending on when construction begins and when it is placed in service. The reverse can also be true: an idea that didn't fit before may deserve a second look. When a category is in flux, the best professionals are aware of the changes and can apply them to their clients’ circumstances.
4. What Happens If the Partnership Donates the Land?
The client moment. Your client has been offered an interest in a partnership that owns land, and was told the partnership might donate the land to a charity, with a deduction passed through to investors.
The question to ask. Before you invest, what would a donation actually mean on your return, and what if it never happens? Start with the client:
Is this an investment or a gift? The payment for a partnership interest is an investment, not a charitable gift. The partnership agreement sets out whether the land is held, developed or donated, and how that decision is made. A donation is not guaranteed.
Does the appraisal reconcile with the purchase price? If a donation is approved, a qualified appraisal estimates fair market value on the donation date. Its highest-and-best-use conclusion must be supported by evidence such as zoning, access and market data, and a substantial difference from the partnership's recent acquisition price should be explained and reconciled.
How much could you actually deduct? Schedule K-1 reports an allocation, not the allowable deduction. For long-term capital-gain land given to a public charity at fair market value, the deduction is generally limited to 30% of AGI, with excess generally carried forward up to five years. Beginning in 2026, there are additional limitations that should be considered.
What will you need to file? Each investor files their own Form 8283, supported by the qualified appraisal and the charity's contemporaneous written acknowledgment. Treas. Reg. §1.6011-9(c)(7) treats certain fee-simple arrangements as listed transactions, so each investor files their own Form 8886; the partnership's filing does not replace the client's.
Why it matters. Start before the client invests. A projection built on the client's income, other gifts, carryforwards and limits shows what a potential deduction may be worth, and at filing you reconcile the K-1 with the client's own return. No appraised value or deduction is guaranteed, so the client's facts, not a projected figure, should drive the decision. Learn more about the three potential paths for undeveloped land.
5. Can You Afford to Have This Money Tied Up, or Lost?
The client moment. Your client had a record income year but spends nearly all of it supporting a growing family and a new home.
The question to ask. If this money were tied up for years, or lost entirely, how would that affect your plans?
Why it matters. Many of these strategies involve operating businesses or illiquid partnership interests with construction, market, counterparty and valuation risk. Capital can be tied up for years, and some or all of it can be lost regardless of the tax treatment. Credits can also be recaptured if property is disposed of or stops qualifying early (IRC §50(a)). A client whose spending nearly matches their income is probably not a fit, however large that income is.
Before Year-End, Ask:
Participation: Will you materially participate, and how will the hours be tracked?
Usability: How much of the benefit can you use this year?
Current law: Does the idea rely on rules that changed in 2025, and are its dates still met?
Property gifts: If a partnership may donate land, does the appraisal reconcile with the purchase price, and what would the limits and filings (Forms 8283 and 8886) mean for your return?
Liquidity and risk: Can you afford to have this money tied up for years, or lost?
The Bottom Line
None of these questions has a universal answer. The right one depends on each client's facts, and the final judgment belongs to qualified, independent tax, legal and financial professionals. What the questions do is change the conversation: instead of reacting to the latest strategy a client has heard about, you start with the client.
Rendio helps CPAs work through questions like these with free educational resources and tools.